The first person must take either stool 9 or 17
(because of symmetry, it doesn't matter which). Assume they pick seat
9. The next person will pick seat 25, since it is the furthest from
seat 9. The next two people will take Seats one and 17. The next three
will occupy 5, 13, and 21. The next six will occupy 3, 7, 11, 15, 19,
and 23. This seats the maximum of 13 people, and no one is sitting next
to another person. If a seat other than 9 or 17 is chosen first, the
total bar patrons will be less than 13.
B says: "Suppose I have red-red. A would have said on her second turn: 'I see that B has red-red. If I also have red-red, then all four reds would be used, and C would have realized that she had green-green. But C didn't, so I don't have red-red. Suppose I have green-green. In that case, C would have realized that if she had red-red, I would have seen four reds and I would have answered that I had green-green on my first turn. On the other hand, if she also has green-green [we assume that A can see C; this line is only for completeness], then B would have seen four greens and she would have answered that she had two reds. So C would have realized that, if I have green-green and B has red-red, and if neither of us answered on our first turn, then she must have green-red. "'But she didn't. So I can't have green-green either, and if I can't have green-green or red-red, then I must have green-red.' ...
Comments
Post a Comment